All tagged 3.5

Maola More Reduced Fat Chocolate Milk

Unnaturally thick without a creamy payoff. Perhaps it's the prebiotic fiber mucking up the works, which doesn't sound appealing in a chocolate milk-- but fortunately doesn't add baggage on the flavor end. Texture aside, it's not an offensive drinking experience, just rather uninspired. Sure, more protein, less sugar, and added fiber are great features for the macro-conscious, but not for the hedonists in pursuit of the world's best chocolate milk. It's not particlulary chocolaty, creamy, or indulgent-feeling, however the sweeteners (sugar and sucralose) impart less distraction than its immediate peers in the genre. That's the most complimentary thing I can come up with.

Organic Valley Lactose Free Lowfat Chocolate Milk (2025)

Well, I agree with the label-- "New Taste." I definitely preferred the old one, which was similarly bland, but had a nicely light-enough cocoa flavor that you could convince yourself it was 'deft' or 'sophisticated.' This version carries one of the stranger cocoa flavors I've had, especially for a meant-for-the-mainstream product. It hits like a cooked vanilla flavor, but even less sexy than that sounds. Strikes me as odd that the ingredients have no hint of vanilla or flavor additives or anything-- how they managed to get this flavor out of organic cocoa will remain a mystery to me, and perhaps is something I should laud as a feat of bioengineering. The remainder of the drink is drably appropriate for the lowfat/lactose free archetype-- a slightly saltier-than-sweet ratio is its most palatable feature. 

Nesquik Chocolate Chip Cookie Milk

Profiles like a cookies & cream flavor with a caramel-like wave that hits mid-sip and sweeps it into another category-- evidently 'chocolate chip cookie.' The aftertaste tapers to an almost fruitiness, that, for me, had hints of canteloupe which I'm sure is unintentional. It's not great, albeit highly congruent with the Nesquik brand.

Hy-Vee Lowfat Chocolate Milk

Decidedly uninspired and uninspiriing-- mild cocoa flavor stretched thinly over a lowfat, no-frills base. There's a slight salty quality which fortunately surfaces above the sweetness, but it's not satisfying in any regard and leaves you with an unnatural astringency in the mouth-- not a great feeling while you're looking in the fridge for a chaser.

Parmalat Reduced Fat Chocolate Milk

Ultra-smooth, and very noticeably ultra-pasteurized. The cooked milk flavor is more prominent than anything else, and the 'chocolate' side of it seems to impact the coloration (which is albeit still light) than the flavor-- where it's almost entirely absent. It doesn't take much to realize it's an empty experience, and should be sold by the thimbleful rather than quart.

Stewart's Lowfat Chocolate Milk

Fairly drab with a sharpish saltiness that causes your tongue to water toward the tip-- not much cocoa presence and the base feels watered down and somewhat depleted. It's a stopgap at best, an underwhelming representation of chocolate milk at worst. Leaning toward 'worst' here.

Trader Joes Reduced Fat Chocolate Milk

The enjoyment peaks early on in the sip with the initial rush of cocoa and moderate sweetness-- but it quickly abates in favor of an intrusive stevia wave-- not quite sharp enough to call it a 'twang'-- but it wrests control of the flavor throughout the 2nd and 3rd trimester-- leaving you with an unsatisfying and slightly drying aftertaste.

Ole' Mother Hubbert Chocolate Milk

Am I missing something here? Grass fed, creamline chocolate milk is right up my alley, but this unfortunately misses on so many levels. I'm left to suppose that I got a bad batch(?)-- though it's decidedly not spoiled (I've had enough of those to know). The flavor is highlighted by a syrupy funk that does not deliver cocoa, cream, malt, or any other desirable characteristics often found in chocolate milk.

Rebel Creamery Chocolate Cream Milk

Very unique combination-- a thick, creamy body with understated, but twangy non-sugar sweetness. Cocoa is hard to locate and takes a back seat to the sweetener and relatively prominent cooked milk flavor. The aftertaste leaves an unsatisfying coating in the mouth, but for just 1g sugar, it sort of feels like a 'win.'

Wawa Cookies and Cream Milk

Reformulated from the previous version, this is every bit as sickly sweet as before, albeit with improved visuals (from what I can remember) and a thin texture built for speed rather than comfort. Sugar junkies, seek this stuff out, but it's way too distractingly sweet for me to recommend in good faith.

Glenview Farms Lowfat Chocolate Milk

Nothing to see here— not in the clichéd cover-up way, but literally, there’s nothing worth your attention in regards to this product. The fact that it’s made available to institutions so they can ‘offer’ chocolate milk is great, but ultimately does the genre reputational damage for those who assume this to be standard.

Sealtest Chocolate Lowfat Milk

Earthy, flat, and noticeably aggregate— perhaps an excavation site in drinkable form— albeit with a deftly tuned sweetness level and otherwise palatable characteristics. It doesn’t take much to stand out in the ‘institutional’ market, but so far it’s a half step above the field.

Dos Pinos Choco Leche

Identifiable as chocolate, but very much on the candy end of the spectrum. An almost fruity sweetness laces the cocoa and immediately frames the conversation  “…well it’s not bad for a…” which of course translates to “it’s not good.” It’s potable, but mature palates beware.

Schneider's Chocolate Lowfat Milk

Nothing offensive, unless you’re aggrieved by an impossibly boring product that would be upstaged by an unsalted pretzel. Fortunately it’s not over-sweet, which is appreciated, but every other meaningful flavor category is underrepresented here as well.